Dear Auntie Kate:How to interpret mixed signals from your 1st cousin? Situation is this: she's in the middle of a divorce from a guy she's been married to for five years. Guy essentially dumped her at least two years ago for girl 10 years younger than himself (at that time girl was 17). Unfortunately cousin and husband have a daughter who'll be 5 years old in December. Cousin is afraid of losing custody of her daughter. There's the context. Here's the problem: when I visited my cousin last December, she mentioned in one conversation that she trusted me most out of all the guys she knows right now. Later that day she changes her mind, says she doesn't trust anyone, not even herself. Okay, if the plot doesn't resemble molasses in January yet, I'll confuse the metaphors by tossing in a wrench: when we first met back in '92 (she was 19 then, now 26, and I was 25 then, now 32), we kissed, fell in love (and three times went as far as carressing/petting, but no further)! and for non-romantic reasons (to keep family and relatives from messing it up, and giving us a chance to figure the whole thing out for ourselves on our own terms), I proposed marriage to her. She agreed. This time around, after an okay day together, on impulse is my guess, she french-kisses me. Not once, but three times. And then tells me that she wouldn't know how to explain to her daughter that, if we got married, her mother and her stepped were related to each other. Also: she didn't want to say anything she didn't mean, and didn't want to lead me on. Quandary: how to react? My reaction, not sure how wise or smart in retrospect, was: I told my cousin I wanted a relationship, not a one-night-stand (amazingly enough, I didn't mumble with my foot in my mouth).
Dear Mr.Mixed,
Well, you are both wallowing around in quite a muddle. Let me just pour another cup of earl gray, take a little powder and worry my brow for a moment. Yes, I think I have it. I am going to give you the very best advice for this kind of situation.
Because of the taboo, uncertainty, sensitivity and rather delightful
temptations involved in cousin relationships, there is only one bit of
advice that can be guaranteed to sort out your situation.
We cousins have to remember that treading on the thin ice of taboos
can sometimes lead to too much ambiguity. Do you know of any flirtatious
cousins who have received an unexpected surprise when taken seriously?
You bet that your Aunt Kate does! Maybe the response was just perfect.
Maybe the response or even the flirtation are shocking, appalling, and
a hurtful breach of trust. Oh yes, it does make for a nasty muddle when
all is hinted, implied or wished away or wished to be. How can we
sort it out? How?
Yes, Mr. Mixed, direct, honest discussion is the only thing that will do. Make a private face to face time when and where it is obvious that you want privacy without sexual implication. A nice lingering visit to a cute little lunch cafe before some preplanned family event would be perfect.
Tell your cousin that you do harbor a long term love and affection for her and that you would like to build a relationship with her once her life settles down. Tell her that you found her attentions sweetly spontaneous and delightful. But also tell her that you realize they were honest, but playful. Let go of any desire that she wants to leap on to the lunch table to start rebuilding the passion in her life. Offer to be her trustworthy, affectionate supporter until her child custody issue is settled, with or without further intimate contact.
Now, the issue of this sweet little daughter - if you read my letters, you know that your Aunt Kate thinks she is main consideration in this discussion. In our experience at cousincouples.com, children have been quite understanding about cousin couple relationships and quite frankly, rarely notice. Taboos are taught, as can be the attitudes of hatred, kindness, love, privacy and intimacy. You just make sure that your lovely young cousin knows that you won't be party to teaching any of those attitudes and emotional habits that are destructive, and that you would love to share and teach the ones that build good, healthy lives. Having read your letter, I am sure you have the communication skills to do it. (But MM, do keep an eye on those mixed metaphors. The will bite you in the end, and confound instead of elucidate.)
Now, where was the forest? Somewhere here behind all the trees, I recall. Oh yes, when the whole situation settles down, we'll just nicknaming you 'ole smoooothy down at the dining room. By doing the right things for your cousin at the right times, you will truly make both she and yourself very happy. Marriage? Well, Kate does love a wedding, but sweetie, let's not add stress and more confusion to an already irrational and frustrating time of life. Let's just get sorted out on the divorce and custody issues and the mixed messages. That should extricate the wrench from the works and get the pot back on the boil!
Yes, Mr. Mixed, you said just the right thing to her. Now stick to it,
and go follow up. Don't come on too heavy, just be her confident and friend.
The rest might well happen for you. If it doesn't, well write another letter
to your Auntie and we'll talk about how to handle the heartbreak of loss.
Your
Aunt Kate
www.cousincouples.com and Auntie Kate are supported entirely by
the efforts of private individuals. Your US dollar contribution,
payable
to "Auntie Kate" can be sent to her attention at Suite #1006, 48
Par-La-Ville Rd., Hamilton, Bermuda. Contributions will be used
to defer
the costs of maintaining www.cousincouples.com and similar activities.